Visit the Sweetwater LLC blog
Visit the Sweetwater LLC blog
Connect with Jim on LinkedIn



Even Low Levels of Some Contaminants Are Harmful


NEW YORK - There is no clearly safe level of exposure to four of the most common environmental toxins in the world, and more should be done to protect the public, researchers argue in a new report.

The toxins in question -- lead, radon, tobacco smoke and byproducts of drinking-water disinfection* -- are ubiquitous, and there is growing evidence that even low-level exposure can have health consequences, according to the report, published in the medical journal PloS Medicine.

'Emerging evidence indicates that exposures must be virtually eliminated to protect human health,' conclude Dr. Donald Wigle, of the University of Ottawa in Canada, and Dr. Bruce Lanphear, of Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center in Ohio.

The problem, Wigle told Reuters Health, is that there are no known safe levels of exposure to these toxins, yet people are persistently in contact with them.

'These are widespread exposures,' he said. 'They're not rare.'

Lead, for instance, is present in the air, soil and water, and it has become clear that even relatively low-level exposure can damage the developing brain in young children and fetuses, leading to learning and behavioral problems. In adults, lead exposure may raise blood pressure and damage the kidneys, brain and nerves.

Disinfection byproducts form when drinking water is treated with chlorine to kill disease-causing microbes. The chlorine reacts with organic materials in the water to create a range of chemicals, including a group known as trihalomethanes (THMs). THMs are known to cause cancer in animals, and some studies have linked them to miscarriage and other pregnancy risks. There is also evidence tying them to bladder cancer in humans.

(Note: Trihalomethanes are a chlorine byproduct estimated by the Water Quality Association to be responsible for 2 – 17% of the diagnosed cases of bladder cancer in the US)

Wigle and Lanphear point to a recent analysis of several studies that found that exposure to water with THM levels of 1 mcg/dL may increase the risk of bladder cancer. In the US, the maximum allowable THM level is 80 mg/L, and in Canada, it's 100 mcg/dL.

Again, Wigle said, these levels may be 'much too high.'

The two remaining toxins he and Lanphear highlight -- secondhand smoke and radon -- also have no apparently safe level of exposure. Radon is a natural radioactive gas found in soil, air and ground water that is known to cause lung cancer.

Radon levels in homes and other buildings vary widely, and health officials recommend that people whose homes have radon levels exceeding 4 picoCuries per liter of air take action -- such as increasing ventilation. But again, Wigle and Lanphear note, there are studies suggesting that radon exposure below this level increases the risk of lung cancer. (Note: If you have radon in your water, your exposure will come when the water is used such as in the shower or at the sink)


SOURCE: PloS Medicine, December 2005.


Story by Amy Norton


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE (modified by me)



* I can eliminate each of these contaminants from your water or indoor air. You may learn more about my water purification products and services here: Residential Water Purification Systems or my air purification systems here: Air Purification.



James P McMahon Ecologist

What's in YOUR Water?


Sweetwater, LLC

Return to:

* * *



Home Water Purification Systems Air Purification  Buy my Ultimate Guide

Water Purifiers Arsenic Iron Removal Commercial  Rainwater

Whole House Water Purification Water Testing  Biography Well Water

Rave Reviews


I don't take American Express